FLASH SALE!   ·   $6.50 OFF every club instantly!   ·  Use code at checkout.   ·   Hurry, expires in
image description


  • Independently rated #1 seven years in a row!
  • Highest Quality - Gourmet peanut butters from boutique providers nationwide!
  • Backed by our exclusive "They'll Love It!" Guarantee!
  • FREE SHIPPING every month in the Continental U.S.!
  • Personalized gift announcement and Peanut Butter Lover's Newsletter!
recommended by
  • image description
  • image description
  • image description
  • image description
  • image description
image description

The Peanut Butter of the Month Club is the perfect gift for anyone who craves the creamy goodness of premium, all-natural peanut butter! Each month our gourmet experts sample dozens of all-natural, specialty-flavored peanut butters from boutique producers nationwide and each monthly shipment features 2 different varieties in incredible gourmet flavors. If you're serious about your peanut butter, you'll be seriously crazy about these incredible selections. We offer 3, 6 and 12-month clubs and a Peanut Butter of the Season Club with new selections each spring, summer, fall and winter.

You can never go wrong withTHE GIFT THAT KEEPS ON GIVING. Mark McGrath,

Trust the experts! As the #1 provider of gourmet gifts of the month, only Amazing Clubs can deliver these delicious peanut butters at this amazing value. And only Amazing Clubs offers our unbeatable "They'll Love It!" Guarantee. It's so simple. They'll love this gift and we guarantee it!

Exceptional Quality Makes an Exceptional Gift

At Amazing Clubs we've served over 2 million happy customers with a better than 99% satisfaction rate. Our customers order again and again because they trust us to deliver the most unique and highest quality peanut butter available anywhere. That means hard-to-find, gourmet selections hand-crafted with only the finest all-natural ingredients and delivered fresh to your door from boutique peanut butter producers nationwide. You won't find any of these peanut butters in your local market or the gourmet food chain stores - they're only available as selections of the Peanut Butter of the Month Club.

Write a Review!

Customer Reviews

  • JD
  • Philadelphia, PA

I gave this to my dad for his birthday gift. He LOVES peanut butter and LOVED this gift. At first i was worried it would be too much peanut butter, but between him and my mom, they managed to consume the jar before the next shipment. I turned out my mom enjoyed them too so my dad hid the final shipments. He said each one he received was different being flavor, texture or origin and he really enjoyed that.

Good stuff
  • JoeyD1
  • NY, NY

Good quality peanut butter. Nicely packaged. Very happy with the purchase.

Peanut Butter Club
  • WednesdayAdaams
  • Grand Rapids, MI

I gave my mom a membership to the peanut butter club as a thank you for always helping me. She is a peanut butter freak and I knew it would be a hit! She LOVED it! She said it was exciting to see which flavors and varieties would come and she had fun trying different things. Such a great gift idea! Will definitely be sending more Amazing Club gifts for Christmas!

Peanut Butter
  • die Oma
  • Warrensburg, MO

My children have renewed this twice for me since my birthday last February. Since I have low blood sugar, I eat some peanut butter each day for breakfast. The peanut butters have been terrific, so much better than the name brands in the store. I look forward to my delivery each month to see what new delights will arrive.

Great Stuff
  • Morgan
  • Morganton, NC

We had received the Peanut Butter Club as a gift and loved it so much we gave it as a gift also. My husband was so excited each time the box arrived. The peanut butter is always wonderful. Love It!!!