Bagel of the Month Club(28 reviews)
Each month we'll deliver a delicious selection of 16 full-sized, authentic New York bagels shipped oven-fresh from some of New York City's premier bagel makers. Each shipment includes two new and different varieties of bagels (8 of each variety, 16 bagels total) made with only the finest, all-natural ingredients and each monthly delivery is covered by our unbeatable "They'll Love It!" Guarantee!
You can choose to send a gift announcement by mail or email or you can print it from your computer for the ultimate in last-minute gift giving! Your gift announcement will include your personal message, details for your recipient about their gift membership, and their delivery schedule. View a sample gift announcement
Each monthly delivery includes our informative bagel lover's newsletter, Whatta Bagel!, with information about our monthly selections, fun bagel facts, serving suggestions and more!
I'm a New Yorker relocated to Georgia and my parents sent me the bagel club to remind me of home. I just received the first delivery and it was excellent! The bagels were fresh and I enjoyed both varieties (Sweet Pumpkin and Country Wheat Everything). The newsletter was also good. 4 stars for now and I'll come back and update after a few more deliveries!
I called with questions and they were very helpful. It's great to speak to people who truly care. The bagels are pretty good too!
I'm from NY and miss my bagels , my girlfriend thought this would be a perfect gift. I was very excited and couldn't wait for my NY bagels to be delivered. First delivery came today and they're excellent. Makes me feel like I'm back home in Brooklyn!
Really good and great customer service! 5 stars all the way!
This was a gift from our smarty pants daughter who just moved to New York. But the jokes on her because we LOVE these bagels! Keep the coming honey!
I had this club for awhile. I wasn't a fan. They send too different varieties every month and some of the are a little out there (Quinoa Multigrain Bagels?). I'm sure some people are into the different flavors but I'd rather have plain old regular bagels and they don't have an option for that. I called customer service and switched to the wine club.
Response from Amazing Clubs
We're sorry you're not having a perfect experience, Mel! Your new membership is all set up and we hope you enjoy your upcoming deliveries from our Wine of the Month Club!
i've been getting these as a gift for some time now and i'm always happy to receive them. there's a wide variety of flavors you will get and some are seasonal (like pumpkin near halloween). the bagels are fluffy and keep well as long as you refrigerate them right after you get them. my favorite flavors are french toast, egg and onion. you also get a newsletter/recipe with each box, which is a nice addition.
I was excited to receive this interesting birthday gift from close friends and I'm still excited 3 months later! The bagels are very good and they send a wide variety of flavors. The parmesan bagels have been my favorite so far!
These bagels are the bomb, yo. No joke, it's like a real new yorker made them himself. Highly, highly recommend these bagels.
We received this as a Christmas Gift. 1 shipment every other month. first shipment was Cinnamon Raisin, and Everything. Neither my husband nor I eat either of these 2 varieties. No changes are allowed. The next shipment was Marble Rye, and Salt bagels. the Marble Rye bagels were actually very good, but we both have high blood pressure and can't eat the salt bagels. Again, they can't be returned.
Response from Amazing Clubs We're sorry you're not having a perfect experience! Did you know there's a way to make sure you LOVE every single selection you receive? If you add your email address to your order we'll email you in advance of every delivery and you'll have the option to skip that month's selection. I've asked a customer service supervisor to reach out to you for your email address and we hope this helps you enjoy the rest of your membership!
Products Every Time.
Get the Lowest Price
Gift card measures a full 6" x 4 1/2" and arrives by mail in an envelope addressed to your recipient.