Free Shipping! Every Gift. Every Day.

Peanut Butter Club

(310 reviews)
Free Shipping in the continental U.S.
#1 Rated Peanut Butter Club Seven Years in a Row! As seen in the Wall Street Journal.

Each month we'll deliver a new and different selection of hard-to-find, gourmet peanut butters from award-winning and boutique producers across the country. Each shipment includes two delicious varieties of small-batch, premium peanut butter produced with only the finest, all-natural ingredients and each monthly delivery is covered by our unbeatable "They'll Love It!" Guarantee!

Personalized Gift Announcement

You can choose to send a gift announcement by mail or email or you can print it from your computer for the ultimate in last-minute gift giving! Your gift announcement will include your personal message, details for your recipient about their gift membership, and their delivery schedule. View a sample gift announcement

Peanut Butter Lover's Newsletter

Each monthly delivery includes our informative peanut butter lover's newsletter, The Peanut Manifesto, with information about our monthly selections, fun peanut butter facts, serving suggestions and more!

As Featured On...
Create Your Club!
How would you like to pay?

If you choose Pay in Full, we'll charge your credit card in full when you place your order. If you choose Pay per Shipment, we'll charge your first monthly delivery immediately and future deliveries on the 10th of each shipping month. Remember, we deliver all clubs to arrive the last week of every month but your personalized gift announcement can be sent as early as today by mail, email or printed from your computer!

Select Club Duration
Please select a club duration
Shipping Frequency?
Shipping Frequency?
Shipping Frequency?
Shipping Frequency?
When should we start shipping?

Amazing Clubs are delivered the last week of every shipping month. If you're sending a gift, we'll send a gift announcement as early as today that includes your personal message and everything they need to know about their membership including the delivery schedule. Just choose "Send a Gift Announcement" during checkout.

Free Shipping in the continental U.S.
As Featured On...
Customer Reviews
Customer Reviews

Every month better than the last!
  Joni | Greenwich, CT

I don't know how they find these amazing peanut butters but every month seems to be even better than the month before. One of the selections last month was "sea salt and honey peanut butter" and it might have been the best thing I ever tasted. I'm a very happy customer to say the least!

10 year customer!
  Doreen | New York, NY

I've been ordering from Amazing Clubs for over 10 years and I've yet to have anything but an amazing experience. This Christmas I sent my husband the peanut butter club and he says it's the favorite gift he's ever received. Thank for making gift giving foolproof!

  JD | Philadelphia, PA

I gave this to my dad for his birthday gift. He LOVES peanut butter and LOVED this gift. At first I was worried it would be too much peanut butter, but between him and my mom, they managed to consume both jars before the next shipment. It turned out my mom enjoyed them too so my dad hid the final shipments. He said each one he received was different and he really enjoyed that.

Peanut Butter Club
  WednesdayAdaams | Grand Rapids, MI

I gave my mom a membership to the peanut butter club as a thank you for always helping me. She is a peanut butter freak and I knew it would be a hit! She LOVED it! She said it was exciting to see which flavors and varieties would come and she had fun trying different things. Such a great gift idea! Will definitely be sending more Amazing Club gifts for Christmas!

Good stuff
  JoeyD1 | NY, NY

Good quality peanut butter. Nicely packaged. Very happy with the purchase.

Can't buy more even though they advertise it
  Jane B. | Hutto, TX

The newsletter they send with the club says that f you like a certain peanut butter you can call them to order more. We've called twice and both times they've been out of stock. The peanut butters are good but don't expect to be able to buy any more.

Response from Amazing Clubs We're sorry about that, Jane. Sometimes we can indeed help our members with additional shipments and sometimes we sell out very quickly or the products are just too limited. I've asked a customer supervisor to call you to see if we can assist you and we're going to do everything we can to make you a happy customer.

Really good selections!
  PBQueenNY | Poughkeepsie, NY

This was a gift from someone who knows I love peanut butter. My favorite was the 4th shipment, which had one called Saratoga Blizzard Butter and was awesome and the other was a natural smooth PB from Krema which was really nice. Overall, it is a unique gift thats still coming!

Great service!
  AKE | San Jose, CA

Really good company and really good service. I've purchased three clubs now, including the peanut better club just last month, and I've heard rave reviews about all three! I highly recommend Amazing Clubs!

Wife loves it!
  Jeremy E. | Mt. Vernon, WA

My wife loves peanut butter but even I was unprepared for how much she would love this gift. She's made it very clear that this is now considered a "lifetime" gift and deliveries better not stop! Looks like I'm here for the long run!

Peanut Butter Club
  duncan | Rose City, MI

This was a wonderful gift from my daughter...she knows how much I love peanut butter

Highest Quality
Products Every Time.

Get the Lowest Price

You May Also Like

back to top
Compare Peanut-Butter Clubs
Handpicked selections
Guaranteed lowest price
Skip or pause a month
Free shipping
They'll Love It! Guaranteed
Number of deliveries
3 Month Club
$34.95 / month ($104.85)
Seasonal Club
$34.95 / month ($139.80)
6 Month Club
$34.95/month $33.95 / month ($203.70)
SAVE $24
12 Month Club
$34.95/month $32.95 / month ($395.40)
Stay updated with the latest from Amazing Clubs!