Peanut Butter Club

4.7 out of 5 from 351 reviews

Free Shipping in the continental U.S.

EXCLUSIVE
SELECTIONS

CHOSEN EACH MONTH BY EXPERTS

As Featured On...

What's Included

#1 Rated Peanut Butter Club Seven Years in a Row!

Each month we'll deliver a new and different selection of hard-to-find, gourmet peanut butters from award-winning and boutique producers across the country.
Each shipment includes two delicious varieties of small-batch, premium peanut butter produced with only the finest, all-natural ingredients and each monthly delivery is covered by our unbeatable "They'll Love It!" Guarantee!

Personalized Gift Announcement

You can choose to send a gift announcement by mail or email or you can print it from your computer for the ultimate in last-minute gift giving! Your gift announcement will include your personal message, details for your recipient about their gift membership, and their delivery schedule. View a sample gift announcement

Peanut Butter Lover's Newsletter

Each monthly delivery includes our informative peanut butter lover's newsletter, The Peanut Manifesto, with information about our monthly selections, fun peanut butter facts, serving suggestions and more!

CHOOSE DURATION TO SEE PRICE

How would you like to pay?

Pay in Full Pay Per Shipment

Select Club Duration:

Ongoing

^$34^.95/month (Continuous shipping until you cancel)

Shipping Frequency?

Continuous shipping until you cancel

3 Months

^$34^.95/month ($104.85 total)

3 deliveries for a total of $104.85

Seasonal

^$34^.95/month ($139.80 total)

Every 3 months (4 total deliveries)

4 deliveries for a total of $139.80
(Every 3 months)

6 Months SAVE $6.00

^$34^.95/month ( $209.70 total)

Now Only ^$33^.95/month ($203.70 total)

^$34^.95 /month ( $209.70 total)

Now Only ^$33^.95/month ($203.70 total)

6 deliveries for a total of $203.70

12 Months SAVE $24.00

^$34^.95/month ( $419.40 total)

Now Only ^$32^.95/month ($395.40 total)

^$34^.95/month ( $419.40 total)

Now Only ^$32^.95/month ($395.40 total)

12 deliveries for a total of $395.40

Shipping Frequency?

Deliveries will start:

Club ships last week of REPLACE_WITH_CURRENT_MONTH.

Gift announcement arrives anytime.

Free Shipping in the continental U.S.

Have Questions?

ASK US ANYTHING Online now

What's Included

#1 Rated Peanut Butter Club Seven Years in a Row!

Each month we'll deliver a new and different selection of hard-to-find, gourmet peanut butters from award-winning and boutique producers across the country.
Each shipment includes two delicious varieties of small-batch, premium peanut butter produced with only the finest, all-natural ingredients and each monthly delivery is covered by our unbeatable "They'll Love It!" Guarantee!

Personalized Gift Announcement

You can choose to send a gift announcement by mail or email or you can print it from your computer for the ultimate in last-minute gift giving! Your gift announcement will include your personal message, details for your recipient about their gift membership, and their delivery schedule. View a sample gift announcement

Peanut Butter Lover's Newsletter

Each monthly delivery includes our informative peanut butter lover's newsletter, The Peanut Manifesto, with information about our monthly selections, fun peanut butter facts, serving suggestions and more!

Previous Selections

We're proud of the hard-to-find, premium peanut butters we deliver to our members every month. Over the last 12 months we've featured the following selections in the Peanut Butter of the Month Club.

May, 2023

Coming Soon...

April, 2023

Shell Dust - Natural Roasted Peanut Butter
Nutty Novelties - Butterscotch Peanut Butter

March, 2023

Ellis Brothers Pecans - We're Nuts Peanut Butter
Wells Made - Banana Chip Peanut Butter

February, 2023

Snider Farms Peanut Barn - Natural Peanut Butter
Appomattox River Peanut Co. - Honey Roasted Peanut Butter

January, 2023

Tare Market - Natural Peanut Butter
Offbeat Butters - Buckeye Brownie Chocolate Peanut Butter

December, 2022

Organiqelle - Natural Creamy Peanut Butter
Fokken Nuts - Sugar Cookie Peanut Butter

November, 2022

Laurel's Butter - Natural Peanut Butter
Nutty Nelson's - Raspberry Truffle Peanut Butter

October, 2022

Nuts to You - Super Crunchy Peanut Butter
Gone Nuts - Bees Knees Honey Peanut Butter

September, 2022

Berke's Peanut Butter - Crunchy Peanut Butter
Sarah's - Banana Bread Peanut Butter

August, 2022

Elizabeth's Nut Butters - Chucky Peanut Butter
Edwards-Freeman Nut Co. - Smooth Peanut Butter with Sea Salt

July, 2022

Bertie's County Peanuts - All-Natural Peanut Butter
Never Too Nutty - Maple Peanut Butter

June, 2022

Vor Nut Butters - All-Natural Peanut Butter
Cape May Peanut Butter - Butterscotch Peanut Butter

May, 2022

Public Goods - Organic Peanut Butter
Oliver Pecan Co. - Strawberry Truffle Peanut Butter

Independently Rated #1
for Seven Years in a Row!

Backed by our exclusive
'They'll Love It!' Guarantee

Highest Quality
Products Every Time.

Get the Lowest Price
Guaranteed!

Peanut Butter Club

What's Included

#1 Rated Peanut Butter Club Seven Years in a Row!

Personalized Gift Announcement

Peanut Butter Lover's Newsletter

Have Questions?

What's Included

#1 Rated Peanut Butter Club Seven Years in a Row!

Personalized Gift Announcement

Peanut Butter Lover's Newsletter

You May Also Like